Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Quick Question

If you could just log in to WoW, pick your char/class when you login and have default PvP gear and items available for all players exclusive to Arena, would you still play WoW? Take away everything MMO and just make it an arena game, would it be a game we'd want to play?

I'm not really sure. I'd like to be able to log in and play any class I want without going through the pain in the ass process of gearing up multiple characters to be arena ready. Want to try that stupid War/War/War/Dru/Dru team? No problem. But I still like the sense of having a 'main' that ties you to the community more strongly, can the two co-exist? I get that WoW is an MMO and it's not that type of game blah blah.

I know a lot of people will say WoW lacks the depth to be fun if played this way; I'm not really sure if it does or not. However the TTR experience has to at least make you think WoW could be fun, at least a little bit, if played this way. Being able to play a few games as a different character without investing hundreds of hours isn't so unreasonable, is it?

(I'm not asking for any game changes just talking GOD)

61 comments:

ive said...

I, for one, would play it.

I only enjoy a few things in this game anymore(duels, arena, some occasional BGing NOT honor grinding), but I REALLY enjoy those things. The only bad part about them is the EXCEEDINGLY HIGH curve to even start doing them competetively. It takes days to level a toon from 1-70, and even after you're done you still have weeks, possibly months of honor grinding to do(depending on twinkage possibility(is that a thing? sounds cool, I'm goin with it)) before you can be competetive.

Oh well, it's still fun to hop on old undergeared toons and fuck around.

Anonymous said...

Exactly the same thing going through my mind recently.

alex said...

With the amount of time I spend working on my text rapping skills in conjunction with my job at Denny's I don't have much time for WoW. But if I had a record contract it's possible I'd play WoW this way. Additionally...

Like fish in barrels I'm keepin you in peril, I leave you slayed like a buffet that just made me sterile.

Someone please battle back It's like i'm rhyming in the mirror, I can only do this shit for like another hundred years.

I spec bloodthirst as my pokedex makes you dead first, my burst can't be countered I'm rollin like Fred Durst.

Fuck with me? I'll summon Togepi, play you quick with a guitar pick like this rogue I see.

This is Yu Gi Oh kid and I've got an ultimate dragon, you move slow as shit man it's like your flow rate's laggin.

Richter said...

the ttr is some of the most fun i've had in a while
it owns

basically, i want a server where i can pick my char like i can pick ryu or guile in sf2. maybe trade out trinkets/weapons and shit

give me guild wars, but without the suck

(too bad blizz will never let it happen)

Raddy said...

richter? o.O

Oppo said...

The devil went down to nagrand,
looking for a soul to steal.
In a bind and way behind,
he was willin to make a deal.
He came across this young man
playin arena and kickin butt
and the devil ebayed in a 70
and said "son lemme tell you what:
I bet you didn't know it,
but I'm a warcraft player too,
and if you care to take a dare,
I'll make a bet with you.
You play a mighty fine hunter, boy,
but give the devil his due
I bet a thousand gold against your soul
cause I think I'm better than you."

The boy said:
"My name's Johnny, and it might be a sin,
I'll take your bet you're gonna regret
cause my hunter's sure to win!"

Johnny go feed up your pet,
make sure your quiver's filled,
this is the test, won't be no rest
till one of you is killed,
and if you win you'll fund some shiny epics
with his gold
but if you lose the devil gets your souuuullllll(Stone)

the devil opened up the game and said
"Oh fuck some my accounts been hacked"
.....

.......


no but really,

the devil opened up the game and much to Johnny's shock,
he showed what he had ebayed - a merc. glad title 'lock.
he flung his face across the keys, it made an evil hiss
and a few GCDs later, the fight sounded something like this:

(Johnny screaming in fear)

When the DRs mounted, Johnny said
"You're pretty good old son,
but that little scare just don't compare
CAUSE I'VE BEEN BUFFED A TON!"

(chorus)
MS on the warlock what-the-fuck...
instant shots hitting like a truck...
since when did arcane shot dispel?!...
no more deadzone?! WHAT THE HELL!?...

The devil's blaming lag, but he knew that he got pwned
and traded Johnny all his gold, cursed a bit then zoned.
Johnny whispered
"Devil, come on back if you ever wanna try again,
I whopped your ass cause I play a class getting bjs from Kalgan."

and he frapsed MS on the warlock what-the-fuck...
instant shots hitting like a truck...
since when did arcane shot dispel???...
no more deadzone?! WHAT THE HELL?!...

Oppo said...

btw I have terribad Cuban cigars from the Bahamas with me. Anyone interested in the dregs of a once-famous industry?

Anonymous said...

Your double post made me CLIMAX. But yeah I play on a private server where I have every character in full s3, its really, really fun and I don't know why Blizzard would deny me that fun. I dunno why would they want me to spend extra time on the game? It has gots me stumped.

Icephyre said...

Raddy, I'm going to one up your cum bucket and call you a cum dumpster. You have been gayed. Now go KY.

<3

Anonymous said...

Make me level one char to 70, then allow me create any char at 70. Allow me to share honour/AP across chars.

Kinda like Death Knight on steroids.

Gaucho said...

the way i see it, i'd even much rather play a game like TTR than the game we play now.

just go on, create - equip - battle for a bit. hell, you'd even could make a lan version out of it, where you'd have your own servers and match up with some homies in 3s and 2s with different combos.

I'd pay for that.

Anonymous said...

this would be the ONLY reason i'd play this game again (i quit a while ago). i don't care how much they buffed xp gain; 1-70 is a waste of time, and gearing it is even more of a waste. there are only so many talent builds and spells in the game before your class becomes disgustingly boring.

Anonymous said...

The problem is that if your class for some reason takes it from behind by the nerfbat, you still have to live with it, even though you dont really feel like it. Its a huge commitment to level & gear another class, thats the problem imo. That the rules change all the time.

Anonymous said...

I would get bored and quit within a month.

Anonymous said...

Wow like that would work in the long run and i think we all know it deep down. what before was "the game is about the journey of gearing" as become "the game is about the journey gaining status". Sort of

Anonymous said...

i meant would NOT work in the long run :D

-same anoy as above

Anonymous said...

Oppo, that was fucking amazing.

Tef said...

I would definitely play the game if it was arena only.

I'd try crazy arena comps I can't justify bothering with now.

This game has nothing except arena. It's a game made by morons, for morons. The PvP has always been lacking compared to UO or AC.

Vontre said...

TTR is totally sweet.

Anonymous said...

i would enjoy it for maybe 2 weeks max. The spells in wow are not exciting or pretty like cabal or something. The maps are limited and small. There is still a frustrating amount of RNG with any class. Losing a tie with a character removes any sense of ingame identity and community in general. Without that community a MMO is a terrible game. Your idea is basically an RTS but with no balance, less gametypes and less maps.

Droid said...

The only way I'd return to WoW is if this was an option. A permanent TTR if you will. In a perfect world Blizzard would take the BG's/Arena and box it up with a new title on it. Then dedicate a team to balancing that game. This way you don't have conflicts with the MMO design/balance.

I love WoW pvp, I hate the MMORPG aspect. So until this ever happens I'll stick with playing StarCraft and SF 3rdstrike (maime) with friends and keep my life on track.

Jason Cochard said...

Yeah that's the thing... I think a lot of us would play WoW if it was log on, pick your character, and go to battle... but I'm 99% sure you wouldn't play it for very long without getting totally bored.

That's how they getcha...

Anonymous said...

I am currently AFK gearing my druid and I *really* want to play something else but I *really* dont have time to level and gear another toon and I *really* dont wanna trade accounts because I dont trust anyone and I *really* wish I hadnt sold my previous accounts.

But at least I have a functioning penis which should make up for the lack of wow satisfaction in my life.

alex said...

Yeaaaaa

There's no way that's *THE* Richter raddy lol


I wish it was the real Richter though =[ I miss him

Wireless said...

Hello. This post is likeable, and your blog is very interesting, congratulations :-). I will add in my blogroll =). If possible gives a last there on my blog, it is about the Wireless, I hope you enjoy. The address is http://wireless-brasil.blogspot.com. A hug.

Anonymous said...

nothing i wanto read more then a mexican blog about wireless modems fuck yeaa

Anonymous said...

i think TTR only would get pretty boring. im personally looking forward to sunwell ganking without flying mounts and i dont think you can get anything like that on TTR without some planned out skirmish going on

kelly said...

its a great idea for the 3v3 event. i dont think i can just only play WoW for arenas tho. When i went to a major city i saw no NPC's so that means no BGs or anything too.
Maybe if there was rated BGs I would be cool with it cause there is more options. Thats kind of the reason i find WoW fun...so many options for so many people.

Barrelroll/dwarfgimli said...

They've been deconstructing what it means to be an MMO for a few patches now.

I buy my crack I smack my bitch right here in orgrimmar

Anonymous said...

Yeah its an old idea and its a great one at that. It's really fun grinding 200k honor to be able to get owned in arena for 3+ months until you have proper gear. Add level 1 to 70.

It's no picknick if you only enjoy the pvp side of this game.

You could like have an "account name" that follows you around, all your characters gets like acrynom or something that shows who you are. Would be quite nice.

Would also be very ok to make special pvp servers for just this, awesome.

Girltalk said...

Fore reals leave the MMORPG for the creepy roleplaying weirdos that like to play a game as a side job. Bring in a separate permanent arena server for the E-ATHLETES and G's from around the world.

Anonymous said...

THIS MESSAGE IS FOR BLIZZARD AND BLIZZARD ONLY. IF YOU ARE NOT BLIZZARD DO NOT READ THIS.

Add "Paid Class Change" to the Account Management features plx. Keep reputations / professions, switch gear for equivalent, give it a huge ass cooldown like 1 year and we're good to go.

Anonymous said...

I don't think it would be a big deal, but it would piss off a lot of raiders. It would just be the last "official" proclamation that PvE progress is PvE progress for the point of PvE progress, with no further undertones are "esoteric" benefits for PvP (such as the Void Star Talisman, Lightning Capacitor, etc).

I don't mind the idea, but it is a HUGE change in design philosophy -- there's a difference between letting PvP'ers have their own gear sets in Burning Crusade and flat-out removing all elements of a PvE-esque grind system from the PvP environment. I don't think it will happen, because the cohesive nature of WoW adds a lot to its allure for the average player.

Anonymous said...

Paid class change is a bad idea.

I do a lot of arenas, and when people emo out, they always talk about rerolling. I'm pretty sure about half of these emos (who are sometimes great players) would get a character change only to regret it a few hours later.

Yeah.

Anonymous said...

Guild Wars- Great PvP game that gives your the ability to choose your class with the skills you want and the gear that you want.

Pretty steep learning curve though.

Anonymous said...

wuzzup with your face mate?

Anonymous said...

LoL quick delete:
http://img255.imageshack.us/img255/2334/hollaou9.jpg

ILLexiul said...

Uhhhh what the fuck are you talking about friend...

Anonymous said...

Honestly I think the idea of a permanent test realm, maybe renamed "practice realm" where you could play whatever class you wanted, but on live servers where the scores matter, I think there really needs to be the character building commitment.

barrelroll/dwarfgimli said...

Blizzard won't do that though obviously, if the prize purse is so large on said "do what the fuck you want, just give us money and have a free epic'd char" realm, what's the incentive to even play hardcore on the live realms?

This game died when the world pvp died imo.

But I'm still here cuz I'm a trooper and my paladin needs some expertise from the offset tier6 pieces in sunwell, ty ty

Fathoms said...

So basically what you're saying is if World of Warcraft became Guild Wars, would it be fun?

Raddy said...

STOP STAELIN PICS OFF MY FACEBOOK YOU NARCS <3

I didn't delete that btw

Anonymous said...

wow youre much younger than i thought

Anonymous said...

:insert neckbeard comment: lol get carried

Raddy said...

I DON'T HAVE NECKBEARD I'M DEAD SEXY F U

Anonymous said...

multiple unexplained wristbands :O hawt

^oo^ said...

oh god the sunnies

Anonymous said...

raddy, which meta for 2.4?

Anonymous said...

Did you have chincancer?

Anonymous said...

sexie

Oppo said...

nono Radikal is my cousin Alex.

The truth is out.

You live in Taiwan and teach English in Asia! The investment stuff is just a cover!

Kolenzo said...

I'd hit it.

alex said...

No jokes about that certain television show huh...HOOOWWWWW DISSAPPPOINTING.

I thought anonymous shitbags would do better than this

Anonymous said...

Perfect match.

http://www.tshirtwatch.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2006/11/view1.jpg

teki said...

Not bad, but quoth raddy: "I don't fucking look like David Schwimmer."

False rad, sorry.

http://www.geocities.com/princess_seesa/David_Schwimmer.jpg

alex said...

ahahahhaha

I was thinking of Reba McEntire actually but w/e

Oh and once again, anonymous fails miserably.

Anonymous said...

Radical vs David Schwimmer Remixed

One of these pictures is not rad, can you spot it?

http://img502.imageshack.us/img502/4233/minidavidschwimmerxm3.jpg

korinth said...

haha burnt rad

Anonymous said...

this is what u get for wanting to be raped and having a facebook raddy!

Anonymous said...

Why would you have to choose between a main and TTR? Keep your main on some server, play him when you get lonely, and jump on the TTR whenever you feel like it. Everyone goes away happy. It's retarded, imo, that Bliz hasn't come up with this yet.

Anonymous said...

I think one of your advertisements caused my internet browser to resize, you might want to put that on your blacklist.